1. Quality of Materials

Big Box Store Fences: Big box stores offer aluminum fencing that is designed to be affordable and accessible to the average homeowner. However, to keep costs low, these fences are often made from thinner, lower-grade aluminum. The finish may also be less durable, potentially leading to faster wear and tear, especially in harsh weather conditions.

Contractor Grade Fences: Contractor grade aluminum fences are made from higher-quality materials, including thicker aluminum and superior finishes that are designed to last longer. These fences are typically powder-coated, providing a stronger, more durable finish that resists fading, chipping, and rusting over time. The higher-grade materials used in contractor-grade fences contribute to their overall strength and longevity.

2. Design and Aesthetic Options

Big Box Store Fences: The design options available at big box stores are generally limited. These fences are often mass-produced with standard designs and colors, which may be suitable for basic fencing needs but might not offer the unique look or customization that some homeowners desire.

Contractor Grade Fences: Contractor grade fences offer a wider range of design options, styles and heights. Manufacturers can often work with you to design a fence that complements your property’s architecture and landscape, providing a more tailored and aesthetically pleasing result.

3. Durability and Longevity

Big Box Store Fences: Due to the lower-quality materials and finishes, big box store fences may not hold up as well over time, especially in areas with extreme weather conditions. They may require more frequent maintenance and could need replacement sooner than contractor grade fences.

Contractor Grade Fences: Built to last, contractor grade aluminum fences are designed with durability in mind. The superior materials and finishes mean these fences can withstand harsh weather, resist corrosion, and maintain their appearance for many years. In the long run, the investment in a contractor grade fence can save money by reducing the need for repairs and replacements.

4. Cost Considerations

Big Box Store Fences: The primary advantage of big box store fences is their lower upfront cost. For homeowners on a tight budget, these fences offer a cost-effective solution for basic fencing needs. However, it’s important to consider the potential long-term costs associated with maintenance and replacement.

Contractor Grade Fences: While the initial cost of a contractor grade fence may be higher, the long-term value is often greater. The superior quality, durability, and higher grade finishes mean fewer repairs and replacements over the life of the fence, potentially saving money in the long run.

5. Warranty and Support

Big Box Store Fences: Warranties on big box store fences are often limited, both in scope and duration. Support may also be less comprehensive, with customer service typically handled by the store rather than a specialized professional.

Contractor Grade Fences: Contractor grade fences often come with more extensive warranties, covering materials and manufacturing processes. Manufacturers usually offer ongoing support, ensuring any issues are promptly addressed. This level of service can provide added peace of mind and assurance that your investment is protected.

Conclusion

When deciding between a big box store aluminum fence and a contractor grade aluminum fence, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of each option. Big box store fences offer a budget-friendly, DIY solution, but may fall short in terms of quality and longevity. On the other hand, contractor grade fences, while sometimes more expensive upfront, provide superior materials and long-term value. For homeowners looking for a durable fence that will stand the test of time, investing in a contractor grade aluminum fence is often the best choice.

You can also see our dimensional comparisons here.

Dimensional Comparisons